Smith (35), along with her boyfriend Jacquen Appollis and their friend Steveno van Rhyn, received their sentences from Judge Nathan Erasmus at a community center in Saldanha, a decision met with loud applause from those present. Despite a massive search effort, Joshlin has not been located since her mysterious disappearance outside her home in Saldanha Bay in February 2024. Judge Erasmus emphasized the lack of remorse shown by the trio, who did not testify during the trial.

The courtroom was filled with emotion as community members expressed their anger and grief, demanding justice for the young girl. Smith's mother, Amanda Smith-Daniels, made a poignant plea for her daughter to reveal the truth about Joshlin's whereabouts, describing the impact of the child's loss on her family. Throughout the trial, testimony from over 30 witnesses painted a grim picture of Smith's actions, with claims that she sold her daughter to a traditional healer.

The Western Cape police have committed to continuing their search for Joshlin, despite the case's grim turn, underscoring their determination to uncover the truth behind her disappearance.

The court proceedings have highlighted not only the tragic circumstances of Joshlin's case but also the wider implications for the community of Middelpos, which has been left "fractured" by the crime. As the investigation continues, residents remain hopeful for answers and justice for a young girl who remains missing.