Critics, however, did not respond favorably to the film; The Telegraph awarded it two stars, commenting that the video game’s inherent charm was lacking, while The Guardian’s review offered even harsher criticism, granting just one star and describing the film as having a "cobbled-together feel." Nonetheless, audiences flocked to theaters, particularly families, defying expectations.

Steve Buck, EntTelligence's chief strategy officer, remarked that the movie exceeded all industry projections and resonated well across various demographics. He noted that about 25% of the audience was under 13 years old and more than half were male, a promising sign for family films. Buck also highlighted that the film achieved the largest domestic opening weekend for 2025 thus far and is Warner Bros' most successful launch since 2023.

Minecraft stands as one of the best-selling video games worldwide, with over 300 million copies sold according to Statista. The film's plot centers around four outcasts who find themselves unexpectedly transported to the Overworld, the game's starting realm. While the film industry has seen its share of gaming adaptations that flopped, successful titles like Sonic and The Super Mario Bros Movie have paved the way for optimism.

In a press release before the film's launch, Jack Black touched on the immense expectations tied to the project, acknowledging its significance for fans around the globe, especially given its generational appeal.