Pope Leo XIV, born Robert Francis Prevost in Chicago, assumed a controversial role in American politics as the first American papacy unfolds. The election of Pope Leo XIV, following a wave of jubilation among the Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement, is met with skepticism as key figures express disappointment over his apparent lack of alignment with "America first" ideology. While his political leanings remain largely speculative, early indications, such as his advocacy for immigrants and the poor, clash with the sentiments of some prominent Trump supporters.
Former White House strategist Steve Bannon, known for his hard-right stance, articulated concerns over potential friction between Leo XIV and President Trump, understanding the new Pope’s social media activity as critical of the U.S. administration. Philadelphia resident and the Pope's brother, John Prevost, echoed that disagreement with the current administration, especially concerning immigration, is likely to manifest.
Despite the shift noted within some Catholic communities, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops released a statement celebrating the historic election while extending their inclusive vision for all Catholics and people of goodwill. However, MAGA supporters, who maintain a significant influence within conservative media circles, expressed displeasure and apprehensions that Pope Leo may align more with liberal ideologies, particularly resembling the perspectives of his predecessor, Pope Francis.
Critics in far-right media, including Bannon’s War Room podcast, have launched vitriol against the Pope, some going as far as labeling him "anti-Trump" and "pro-open borders." Debates around Leo XIV's stances on critical issues like immigration and gun control surfaced, with his social media presence casting doubt on his alignment with the Trump administration's views.
As responses continue to roll in, many await to witness how Pope Leo XIV will navigate the intersection of faith and politics, alongside a deeply divided American Catholic landscape.
