The cardinals of the Roman Catholic Church, fatigued and hungry after an extended meditation session, ended their first vote in the Sistine Chapel without a clear consensus. As they regrouped at Casa Santa Marta, the guesthouse where they were isolated from the outside world, discussions began to shift the electoral narrative. Front-runner Cardinal Pietro Parolin of Italy, who previously led the Vatican under Pope Francis, was unable to capture unanimous backing, primarily due to concerns regarding his leadership style, which lacked the collaborative approach Francis championed.

Cardinal Peter Erdo from Hungary, at 72 years old and supported by a conservative coalition that included African allies, also found momentum hard to sustain given the electorate's lean towards those appointed by Francis.

Amidst this competitive landscape, Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, a 69-year-old American, emerged as a notable contender after an unexpected surge during the initial voting. The subtle yet compelling rise of Prevost unfolded in the evenings of the conclave, eventually leading to his election as Pope Leo XIV, a choice that surprised many both inside and outside the church.

With new perspectives on governance hinted at by this unexpected choice, the election of Prevost signals a potential shift in the future trajectory of the Catholic Church.