Federal Threats Over New York's Immigrant Driver Licenses

Sat Dec 13 2025 21:59:54 GMT+0200 (Eastern European Standard Time)

U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has raised concerns that New York is issuing driver licenses unlawfully to immigrants, threatening over $73 million in federal funds unless the issues are rectified.

New York faces federal scrutiny as Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy claims that over half of the commercial driver licenses issued to immigrants are valid beyond their work permit expiration. Duffy has threatened to withdraw $73 million in highway funds unless the state resolves these issues, with state officials adamantly defending their compliance with federal rules. The controversy follows an audit revealing improper licensing practices that could jeopardize public safety.

U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy announced on Friday that New York's issuance of driver licenses to immigrants is problematic, with many licenses remaining valid well past the expiration date of the holders' work permits. Duffy has threatened to withhold $73 million in federal highway funds unless the state clarifies its licensing system.

According to Duffy, an audit showed that more than half of the 200 licenses inspected in New York were improperly issued, with numerous licenses defaulting to validity for eight years, regardless of the status of the immigrant’s work authorization. He cited specific instances where licenses were issued despite the expiration of work permits.

New York officials, however, assert that they comply with federal regulations and have taken active measures to verify the immigration status of drivers. DMV spokesperson Walter McClure refuted Duffy’s claims and emphasized the state's commitment to adhering to federal guidelines.

The controversy has emerged amid growing federal scrutiny of states that issue commercial driver licenses to non-citizens. States like California, Pennsylvania, and Minnesota have also faced similar audits, prompting drastic measures in response to identified issues.

Duffy's concerns are part of a broader federal initiative aimed at enhancing road safety by ensuring that all drivers, especially those operating large vehicles, are qualified. He highlighted the urgent need for governmental accountability in the wake of a deadly truck accident in Florida caused by an unauthorized driver.

With New York having 30 days to respond, the situation remains tense as state officials continue to defend their practices against federal allegations.