On Wednesday, during a court proceeding, Judge Steven Hippler detailed the terms of the agreement. Kohberger conspicuously waived his right to appeal or seek leniency, answering "yes" when asked if he pled guilty because he was indeed guilty. Initially, Kohberger had entered a not guilty plea but has since taken responsibility for the heinous act. The court heard that along with four counts of first-degree murder, he also faced a burglary charge.

Several emotional reactions ensued in the courtroom as the victims' names were read. Kohberger's demeanor, however, remained cold and unchanging as he acknowledged his guilt. Prosecutors revealed that Kohberger planned the attack weeks in advance, buying a knife online. The absence of the murder weapon, despite the recovery of the knife sheath at the crime scene, raises questions about the motives behind the attacks—questions that will remain unresolved due to the plea deal.

The decision has sparked a rift among the victims' families. Kaylee Goncalves' father expressed his disappointment, suggesting the state made a grievous miscalculation. Contrarily, the family of Madison Mogen expressed support for the agreement, focusing on achieving closure rather than vengeance. Kohberger's past affiliation with Washington State University placed him near the victims, yet it remains unclear if he ever had any personal connection with them.

He was arrested in January 2023 after investigators matched DNA found at the crime scene to that of Kohberger. The case continues to unfold, with the formal sentencing scheduled for July 23, where it is anticipated he will be sentenced to life in prison without parole.